A calm comparison
Other ways to keep selling licenses.
These notes follow public docs and product pages. They are not a ranking, and they skip numbers those pages do not publish in a way we can stand behind. Prices and limits change. Read the current page before you pick.
| Keyharbor | LicenseManager | Bunny | Creem | Polar | Dodo | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Where it runs | Your Cloudflare account | A server you install | Bunny's cloud | Creem | Polar | Dodo Payments |
| Who charges the customer | Your payment provider | Your shop | Your payment provider | Creem, as merchant of record | Polar, as merchant of record | Dodo, as merchant of record |
| Existing Lemon Squeezy keys | Import the key string and instances, then change the base URL | Their own API, so the app call changes | Their shutdown post says existing keys do not carry over | Creem issues its own keys | Polar issues its own keys | They document an import API; validation is their API |
| License check | Same activate, validate, and deactivate shape as the public License API | The server you host, with their API | Their validate call, which returns a signed token | Creem's license API | Polar's customer-portal license API, which asks for an organization id | Dodo's activate, validate, and deactivate JSON API |
| Offline | Guidance for a grace period in your app. The check itself is online. | Check their current docs | They document an offline license for air-gapped installs | Check their current docs | Check their current docs | Check their current docs |
LicenseManager at license-manager.app is a self-hosted license server with a one-time price on their site. Your app talks to the server you install. That API is theirs, so the change in a desktop app is larger than a base URL. licensemanager.dev is a different, hosted product. It documents its own validation API and an import path from Lemon Squeezy, including offline signed tokens.
Bunny is hosted subscription billing and license keys. Their own writing says they are not a merchant of record, that they issue new keys, and that Lemon Squeezy keys do not carry over. Validation returns a signed token, and they document an offline license.
Creem is a merchant of record with a license-key add-on. Keys and the license API are Creem's. A checkout webhook can include the keys they issued. Keyharbor does not reuse that key string; it mints a UUID in the License API shape.
Polar is a merchant of record with a license-key benefit. Activation and validation go to Polar's API and include your organization id.
Dodo Payments is a merchant of record. License keys are an entitlement, with their own activate, validate, and deactivate calls, and an API for importing a key you already have. The host and the JSON are Dodo's.
Keyharbor does not process the sale. It keeps the license check on infrastructure you control, in the shape your app already speaks.